What to Do When a Record Label Asks You to Hold a Demo
Clarify what a record label’s exclusive demo request covers, disclose earlier submissions, and put a clear end date on any review hold.
The short answer
Ask the label whether it wants a private listen or a temporary pause on other submissions. If it wants a hold, disclose who already has the recording as appropriate, agree on the exact track and the end date and time, and confirm how you’ll handle any pending replies before you say yes.
Three things to know
- 01
Check the recipient’s current submission policy before you send a demo or offer a hold.
- 02
Disclose earlier submissions and clarify whether the request covers new sends, existing conversations, or both.
- 03
Put the agreed deadline and what happens at expiry in the same email as the track and version.
What goes in the demo review log?
Build on your existing recipient and version log. Keep one row per recording and recipient, and update that row when a reply or deadline changes the plan.
- 01
Recording and recipient
Save the title, mix, recipient, submission channel and send date.
- 02
Pending access
Note which earlier recipients still have access, which replies are open, and what you disclosed to the new label.
- 03
Hold terms
Save the confirmation, the actions you agreed to pause, and the end date with time zone.
- 04
Next action
Set a reminder before expiry. Record whether to resume outreach, request a written change, or seek advice.
What does the label mean by an exclusive demo?
Ask whether the label wants to hear the recording privately, be the only label receiving new submissions for a set period, or have a formal right to make a decision about the release. Those requests affect your options differently. Movement’s demo policy asks for demos that haven’t been shared with other labels. Lunovia’s submission terms allow artists to keep pitching during review. Start with the recipient’s own published instructions, then ask about anything the email adds.
What if another label already has the track?
Check sent mail, portal submissions, and pooled submissions for the recording. Use the recipient and version log from the Records private listening guide. Add who can still hear the track, what you disclosed, and which replies are pending. Elektrax’s demo form asks directly about prior sends. Disclose them accurately and confirm whether the requesting label will review the track on those facts. If its policy excludes previously shared tracks, ask about a different eligible recording or pass on the submission. Removing a listening link leaves the earlier send in your history.
How do you pin down the review window?
Name the track and mix, the start and end date with time zone, and the actions you’d pause. Ask whether you can answer someone who already has the track and what to do if a decision hasn’t arrived by the deadline. Eleatics’ demo page gives artists a defined three-week window and explains what to do after silence. For a direct request, use your own release calendar and any existing commitments to decide what time you can offer. Confirm the end of the hold with the label.
What can you write back before accepting?
Sample reply: “Thanks for asking to hear Glass Harbor, mix v2. One other label already has the private link. If you can review it on that basis, would a pause on new label submissions until Friday, November 20 at 5 p.m. Vancouver time work? I’d keep the earlier link active and tell you if an offer comes in. Can you confirm I can resume sending after that time if we haven’t agreed on an extension?” Keep the proposed terms together so both sides can refer back to the same email.
How would you handle two open label inboxes?
In this fictional example, an artist sent Glass Harbor to Label A on Monday. Label B asks for a hold on Tuesday. B agrees in writing to review while A keeps its link, with new sends paused until Friday at 5 p.m. Vancouver time. On Thursday, A asks if the track is available and wants a decision by noon Friday. The artist tells B about the conflicting deadline and asks whether B can decide or release the hold early. They check the confirmed terms before replying to A about availability. If B wants more time, the artist can decide whether an extension fits both conversations.
When should you pause for a closer review?
Stop and ask for clarification if a request reaches beyond the named recording, sets no end date, or affects a confirmed rollout or another commitment. If the request includes a signing option, rights language, or unfamiliar terms, ask qualified music counsel to review the wording before you agree. Use the label agreement guide to identify questions for that discussion.
Frequently asked questions
- Can I send the same demo to multiple labels?
- Check each label’s current submission policy and any agreement you’ve already made. If the policies conflict, clarify before sending.
- Does a private listening link make my submission exclusive?
- A private link controls how people find the track. Confirm any promise about who else can receive it with the recipient.
- What if I sent a different mix to another label?
- Describe which mix was shared and ask whether the recipient treats both mixes as the same demo for review.
- Can I send a different song while one is on hold?
- Check what the hold covers. Ask for clarification if the request mentions a project, EP, or other recordings.
- What if the label asks to extend the hold?
- Check for upcoming release or reply deadlines, then agree to a new end time only if it still fits.